Houses for sale in Sutton Saint Nicholas, HR1, Herefordshire

There are 52 results for Sutton Saint Nicholas, HR1, Herefordshire. Property prices across these results range from £193k to £1.09M with an average price of £432k.


Properties for sale in Sutton Saint Nicholas, HR1, Herefordshire

Dropdown arrow

Properties for sale near Sutton Saint Nicholas, HR1

Home

Sell or Let Your Property

If you are looking to sell your house, let it out, or receive a property valuation, an expert can help you.
Click the button below to get started.

Property market around Sutton Saint Nicholas

Average asking price £390k within 5 km · typical £358k
Most prices £160k – £1.19M within 5 km
Homes for sale 4 in Sutton Saint Nicholas · 214 within 5 km
New to the market 41 in the last 30 days · within 5 km
Typical time to sell 11 weeks last 12 months · within 5 km
Asking prices, year on year +13.3% homes newly listed · within 5 km
Typical sold price £300k 324 sales in 12 months · within 5 km
Gross rental yield 5.4–7.6% houses 5.4%, flats 7.6% · within 5 km

What's for sale

214 homes within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas · share, count and typical price
Detached houses 36.9% 79 · £435k
Other homes 17.3% 37 · £372k
Semi-detached houses 17.3% 37 · £325k
Terraced houses 15.9% 34 · £216k
Bungalows 7.9% 17 · £440k
Flats and apartments 2.8% 6 · £162k
Land and plots 1.9% 4 · £263k

How many bedrooms

within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas · share, count and typical price
1 bedroom 2.9% 6 · £145k
2 bedrooms 15.8% 33 · £215k
3 bedrooms 39.2% 82 · £325k
4 bedrooms 35.9% 75 · £450k
5+ bedrooms 6.2% 13 · £699k

Price bands

214 homes within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas
Under £220k 18.2% 39
£220k – £320k 20.6% 44
£320k – £400k 21.0% 45
£400k – £530k 19.6% 42
£530k and over 20.6% 44

Houses and flats compared

HousesFlats
Share of homes for sale78%3%
Typical asking price£365k£162k
Average bedrooms3.31.8
Typical time to sell11 weeks3 months
Typical sold price£306k£150k
Gross rental yield5.4%7.6%

Asking prices over time

typical asking price of the homes first listed each quarter within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas · −6.0% since 2024 Q4 Median asking price per quarter in Sutton Saint Nicholas 2024 Q4: £350k (200 new listings) £350k 2024 Q4 2025 Q1: £290k (267 new listings) £290k 2025 Q1 2025 Q2: £320k (315 new listings) £320k 2025 Q2 2025 Q3: £300k (332 new listings) £300k 2025 Q3 2025 Q4: £280k (219 new listings) £280k 2025 Q4 2026 Q1: £350k (276 new listings) £350k 2026 Q1 2026 Q2: £350k (263 new listings) £350k 2026 Q2 2026 Q3: £329k (186 new listings) £329k 2026 Q3

Schools in Sutton Saint Nicholas

1 primary · 0 secondary · 100% rated good or outstanding
  • Sutton Primary Academy primary · Outstanding

Based on 214 homes for sale on Houses now, 918 listings that left the market in the last 12 months, the asking prices of the homes listed over the last two years. Sold prices: HM Land Registry Price Paid Data, Aug 2025 to Aug 2026 (Crown copyright). Schools: Ofsted. Updated November 2026.

Frequently asked questions about buying in Sutton Saint Nicholas

What is the average house price in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

There are only 4 homes for sale in Sutton Saint Nicholas itself, so these figures cover the 214 homes for sale within 5 km. The average home for sale within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas is priced at £390,000. A few very expensive homes pull that average up, so a more typical price is £358,000.

How much does a 2 or 3 bedroom home cost in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

A typical 2-bedroom home within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas costs £215,000 and a 3-bedroom home £325,000. So the extra bedroom adds about £110,000. 1-bedroom homes start at around £145,000, and 4-bedroom homes are about £450,000.

What price range should I expect in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

Most homes within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas are priced between £160,000 and £1.19 million, leaving out the very cheapest and most expensive. One in five costs less than £220,000, and one in five £530,000 or more.

How many homes are for sale in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

There are 4 homes for sale in Sutton Saint Nicholas on Houses right now. Within 5 km there are 214, and the listings on this page include the nearest of them. 41 new listings came onto the market within 5 km in the last 30 days.

Are house prices going up in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

Yes. Homes put up for sale within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas over the last 12 months were advertised at a typical £340,000, 13% higher than the year before (£300,000). By size, 1-bedroom homes are down 18%, 3-bedroom homes are up 10% and 4-bedroom homes are down 2%.

How long does it take to sell a home in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

Within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas, homes usually sell or come off the market within about 11 weeks. About 24% go within the first month, and a quarter take longer than about 5 months. Houses go faster, in about 11 weeks against about 3 months for flats.

What do homes actually sell for in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

In the year to August 2026, 324 homes sold within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas at a typical price of £300,000, according to HM Land Registry. Houses sold for about £306,000 and flats for about £150,000. Asking prices today are a little higher, at £358,000, as sellers usually ask above what homes finally sell for.

What rental yield can I get in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

About 7.6% gross for flats and 5.4% for houses. That compares typical rents with what flats and houses actually sold for within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas over the last year. Running costs, voids and mortgage interest are not taken off.

What type of homes are for sale in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

Detached houses are the most common, about 4 in 10 homes for sale within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas. Semi-detached houses come next, followed by terraced houses. Flats and apartments are the cheapest, at about £162,000, and bungalows the most expensive, at about £440,000.

Are homes in Sutton Saint Nicholas freehold or leasehold?

Almost all homes for sale within 5 km of Sutton Saint Nicholas are freehold and the rest leasehold, which is mostly flats. There are 17 new-build homes on the market too.

What are the schools like in Sutton Saint Nicholas?

There are 1 primary and 0 secondary schools in Sutton Saint Nicholas.